Onopordum

but supplemented
1Stems thinly arachnoid or glabrescent; stem wings narrow, spinose-lobed
1'Stems white-tomentose; stem wings conspicuous, lobulate, with numerous rigid spines
2Leaves deeply pinnatisect, almost to midrib
2'Leaves irregularly and not very deeply lobed, incisions less than 50% in the middle of the leaf